Comparing Roofing Materials

When selecting a roofing material there are many factors to take into consideration beyond cost. Here’s a side-by-side comparison of metal roofs and other common roofing materials. You’ll be surprised at how close you can get on price compared to asphalt roofs!

l

WARRANTY

MAINTENANCE

AESTHETIC

ENVIRONMENT

Metal

Metal

  • 30-50+ years
  • Plus workmanship warranty from installer
  • Inspection every year
  • Repairs and replacements are rare
  • Average lifespan 50+ years
  • Can be repainted up to 50 years after install
  • Shingles can match look of any traditional roofing material
  • Standing seam panels offer a distinctive, timeless look
  • Available in a wide range of colors and styles
  • Energy efficient
  • Made of recycled material
  • 100% recyclable
Asphalt

Asphalt

  • Average warranty of 10-30 years
  • Inspection every year
  • Shingle replacement common
  • Re-caulking and sealing as roof ages
  • Average lifespan 15 years
  • Traditional asphalt shingle look
  • Variations in color shading common
  • Available in a limited selection of colors
  • Made from crude oil and other chemicals
  • Ends up in landfills after short lifespan
Tile

Tile

  • 30-50+ year warranty
  • Periodic inspections once a year
  • Occasional repair of cracked and sliding tiles
  • Average lifespan 50+ year
  • Wide range of styles available
  • Limited color selection available
  • Considered eco-friendly
  • Energy efficient
Shake

Shake

  • 5-year warranty is standard
  • Maintenance required every 2-4 years
  • Susceptible to mold growth, rot and leaking
  • Average lifespan 30 years
  • Rustic and tapered for a natural appearance
  • Considered an eco-friendly roofing material if sourced from a sustainable FSC approved manufacturer